We had a plan! Olivia is the shy one so we would put her on Zachary's lap on Santa's lap. Maybe she wouldn't realize what was happening. Much to our surprise, Olivia was fine...not smiling, but just fine. Abby immediately started crying. We put her on Zach's other knee, so we could quickly get this picture. Abigail was crying a second before it and after it, but we caught it just right.
More pictures of our wonderful day to come.